I have just finished the first book, Beyond the Reflection's Edge, in the Echoes From the Edge series by Bryan Davis.
This post is simply my thoughts, and should be taken with a grain of salt.
(WARNING: This first bit is something of a rant.) The book ended without an ending! What?! Even books in a series should have some sort of wrap up; Davis did this in his other two series (Dragons in our Midst, and Oracles of Fire), but this book just ended like a chapter should--not a book. Also, if you are going to be Christian, be OVERTLY Christian. Don't just throw God in every once in a blue moon. This book had fewer learning steps for the main character than Davis' other books did. Although the characters mistakes in Davis' other books completely exasperated me, they made me think harder; I like books that make me think and challenge me. Lastly, I wish the characters would just act like brother and sister. They are just sixteen! I want to see a relationship between Christian young people that is just a brother and sister type relationship. Some of the things that happened between Nathan and Kelly in the book could bring about feelings of regret on the part of the reader that he/she does not have that type of relationship, and those feelings can easily push someone towards an unhealthy relationship. (END OF RANT)
(REVIEW) This book is for a young adult audience. I would not read it to or allow anyone to read it who is under the age of 13. The content is graphic, especially if your mind turns books into more of a movie than just words on a page. This book is Christian fantasy. It is about a young man and woman who are caught in the middle of inter dimensional travel, while trying to save the young man's parents. All three dimensions reflect the same world, they are just on different time schedules. With the threat of the three dimensions colliding into one Nathan and Kelly must work together to save the cosmos. Davis can definitely keep you on the edge of your seat, but since this book doesn't have an ending I cannot give a full review as to whether it should be read to the end or not; I need the end of the story. (END OF REVIEW)
(BLIP ON BRYAN DAVIS) (From the back of the book) Bryan Davis is the author of the bestselling fantasy series Dragons in our midst and oracles of fire. He and his wife, Susie,have seven children and live in western Tennessee, where he continues to cook up his imaginative blend of fantasy and inspiration. (Not from the back of the book.) Davis and his wife are homeschooling Christian parents. Davis started writing small stories for his children, and later was nudged by God (from the way I understood it) to step out on a limb and write for a living.
Saturday, May 10, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
Yay I'm the first one to comment on this new blog! (Okay, that's my obnoxiousness for the day...I mean hour.) Actually, I think this is a really cool idea especially since you guys read books so much fast then my family. Ahem...we are still plodding through the "Dragon books" by Davis. Anyway thanks for being creative and for giving me another site to surf when I'm wasting time I don't really have to waste:) Love you both!
Love,
Shannon
Galadriel, I do not mind of you wish to disagree with me on the review of this book, but to post another review over mine is slightly rude. If you are trying to get points for Mr. Davis' contest then I request you post reviews some where else.
I read that book about a week ago. It was the first book I've ever read of B Davis, still is!, and, to be honest, it didn't hook me. Great book, I'd read the 2nd one if I had it, but not enough to make me go buy it! Great review. You said what you thought ;D
Post a Comment